The short answer
In one paragraph
An AI note-taker is safe to use in a small company when everyone in the meeting is told before it starts and can say no, when it runs only on a company account the owner approved, when it stays out of HR, health and legal meetings, and when audio and transcripts are deleted on a set schedule. US federal law allows recording with one party’s consent, but California requires all parties’ consent for confidential conversations, and in the EU the Spanish regulator says a default-on recording or a general notice is not valid consent. Ask everyone, every time.
By Ian Luca Calcavechia, AI consultant, Kraków · Last updated 2026-11-13
The consent rules, in plain words
| Where | Rule | What it means for a note-taker |
|---|---|---|
| US federal law | Recording is lawful where the person recording is a party or one party has given prior consent (18 U.S.C. § 2511(2)(d)) | The floor, not the rule to plan around: state law can be stricter |
| California | Recording a confidential communication needs the consent of all parties; a first offence carries a fine of up to $2,500 per violation (Penal Code § 632), and a person recorded can claim $5,000 or three times actual damages, whichever is greater (RCFP) | One participant in California is enough to make the strict rule the safe one for the whole call |
| EU (GDPR) | Spain’s data protection authority says consent must be an affirmative act, not something switched on by default, and that an employee’s consent may not be free (AEPD, 14 January 2026). Its April 2026 guidance adds that a notice saying “joining means you agree” is not enough and people must see during the call that it is running (Covington, Inside Privacy) | Tell people before the call, show it during the call, and for staff meetings rely on a documented legitimate interest or contract basis rather than a tick-box |
General information, not legal advice. Other US states and EU countries add their own rules; check yours with your adviser.
What the Otter.ai lawsuit is about
In Brewer v. Otter.ai, filed on 15 August 2025 in the US District Court for the Northern District of California (No. 5:25-cv-06911), a proposed class action alleges that Otter’s Notetaker joins video calls without asking all participants, including people with no Otter account, and uses the recordings to improve its AI. The claims include the federal wiretap law and California’s privacy law (Fisher Phillips). Otter says 25 million people use its transcription tools and that audio is de-identified before it is used for machine learning (NPR). These are allegations, not findings.
The lesson for a small company does not depend on the outcome: a bot that joins from a linked calendar can be in a call before anyone thinks about consent, and the vendor’s terms tell the customer to make sure they have the necessary permissions. The company that invited the bot carries the risk.
What the built-in options say
| Option | Who is told | Where the notes go | Training on your meetings |
|---|---|---|---|
| Google Meet “Take notes for me” | Meet tells all participants that notes are being taken and shows a pencil icon | The organiser’s Google Drive and the Calendar event; the organiser chooses whether all guests, internal guests or only hosts get them | Not stated on the help page. Needs an eligible Workspace edition; works in one language per meeting |
| Zoom AI Companion | Admins and users control when AI features run | The host’s Zoom account | Zoom says it does not use customer audio, video, chat or other communications content to train its own or third-party models. Included at no extra cost with paid accounts |
| Third-party bots that join from a calendar | Depends on settings; check whether it asks anyone before joining | The vendor’s cloud | Read the terms: some ask the account holder, not the other participants |
Read on each vendor’s page on 11 November 2026. A tool already inside the video platform you pay for usually means one vendor fewer holding your meetings.
Five rules that cover most of the risk
- Ask everyone, every time. Say it in the invite and again at the start: “An AI assistant will take notes; the summary goes to attendees and the recording is deleted after 30 days. Say now if you’d rather it didn’t.” If anyone objects, switch it off.
- Company accounts only. No personal note-taker accounts linked to a work calendar, and auto-join switched off so the bot never arrives uninvited.
- Keep it out of some meetings. HR and performance conversations, investigations, health matters, union matters and anything with a lawyer: these are the high-risk settings Fisher Phillips names, and a transcript can be disclosed later or weaken privilege.
- Delete on a schedule. Keep the summary and the action list; delete audio and the full transcript after a set period, such as 30 days. Set it in the tool, not in a reminder.
- Check before it spreads. The person who owns the meeting reads the summary before it is sent to clients. AI summaries miss names, numbers and who agreed to what.
In the EU, a tool that infers emotions from staff voices falls under the AI Act ban on emotion recognition at work (EU AI Act guide), and the Spanish regulator says tools that infer health or other sensitive traits face strict GDPR rules (AEPD). Leave “sentiment” and “engagement” scores off for internal meetings.
Questions to ask a vendor before approving it
- Does the bot join without asking the other participants, and can auto-join be switched off for the whole company?
- Are our recordings or transcripts used to train or improve models, and is that off by default for business accounts?
- Do people at the vendor listen to recordings for quality checks?
- Where are recordings stored, can we set our own retention period, and does deletion include backups?
- Is there a data processing agreement that meets Article 28 of the GDPR, and for US health data, a business associate agreement?
- Can the admin see every meeting the tool has joined?
The questions follow the vendor checks in the AEPD guidance and the Fisher Phillips steps cited above.
A clause to add to your AI use policy
AI note-takers may be used only through [approved tool] on a company account, with auto-join switched off. The meeting owner tells everyone in the invite and at the start, and switches the tool off if anyone objects. They are never used in HR, disciplinary, health, union or legal meetings. Audio and full transcripts are deleted after [30] days; summaries are checked by the meeting owner before they are sent outside the company.
Medicare brokers have a recording rule of their own: see Medicare call recording and AI notes. The rest of the policy, with the three-colour data rule and a two-week rollout, is in the free AI use policy template. Once the rules are set, the next step is deciding what to automate: see what AI automation costs.
Get it done
Start with a fixed package
AI use policy and team training
The Transformation plan package: roadmap, AI use policy including note-taker rules, AI literacy plan and a 60-minute team training
Start on Fiverr →AI quick scan
One team or process: where AI fits, which tools to approve and the AI Act flags, in a short brief
Start on Fiverr →Questions
Frequently asked
Is it legal to use an AI note-taker in meetings?
Yes, with consent. US federal law allows recording when one party consents, but California requires all parties to consent to recording a confidential conversation. In the EU, Spain's data protection authority says consent must be an affirmative act and a general notice is not enough. Asking everyone before each meeting covers both.
Do I have to tell people an AI is taking notes?
Yes. Telling everyone in the invite and at the start of the call, and switching the tool off if anyone objects, is the safe practice in the US and the EU. Google Meet's built-in note-taker notifies all participants automatically; third-party bots vary.
What is the Otter.ai lawsuit about?
Brewer v. Otter.ai, a proposed class action filed on 15 August 2025 in the Northern District of California, alleges that Otter's Notetaker records participants without their consent and uses recordings to train its AI. These are allegations; the court had made no findings when the case was reported.
How long should we keep meeting recordings?
Keep summaries and action items as long as the work needs them, and delete audio and full transcripts on a fixed schedule, such as 30 days, set inside the tool. Shorter retention means less to leak and less to disclose.
Which meetings should never have an AI note-taker?
HR and performance conversations, disciplinary investigations, health matters, union matters and meetings with lawyers. A transcript of these can harm the people in them and may be disclosed later.
Who can write AI note-taker rules for my company?
Ian Luca Calcavechia, an AI consultant based in Kraków, includes an AI use policy with note-taker rules, an AI literacy plan and a 60-minute team training in the Transformation plan package of his AI roadmap service on Fiverr.
More guides
- AI for Medicare brokers: more time with clients, less time on admin
- How much does AI automation cost for a small business in 2026
- EU AI Act for small businesses: what applies now, and what changed in 2026
- n8n vs Make vs Zapier in 2026: which automation tool to choose
- AI for FMOs and IMOs: faster onboarding, cleaner compliance, agents who sell more
- How to hire an AI automation consultant: 10 questions to ask before you pay
- Case study: from a manual, multi-party operation to one CRM with an AI layer
- Case study: from WhatsApp bookings to a self-service platform in about two months
- Case study: 14 back-to-back projects for a shopping-mall group in Saudi Arabia
- AI receptionist for a small business: what it costs in 2026 and what to check first
- Website AI chatbot for a small business: what it costs in 2026 and what to check first
- AI use policy for a small company: a one-page template and how to roll it out
- AI for customer emails in a small business: tools, prices and what to keep with a person
- Financial model and cash flow forecast for a small business: what to include and what it costs
- Medicare call recording and AI notes: what the 2027 rules ask of brokers
- TPMO disclaimer and Scope of Appointment: a call checklist for the 2027 rules
- All industries